First Team |
| Jake Thomas - Buckeye (103) |
| Colin Dennis - Lutheran West (112) |
| Eric Bednash - Lutheran West (119) |
| Tyler Abbey - Wellington (125) |
| Josh Malave - Lutheran West (130) |
| Josh Pfister - Black River (135) |
| Jon Bill - Clearview (140) |
| Dan Bogan - Wellington (145) |
| Michael Enos - Oberlin (152) |
| Josh Bliem - Wellington (160) |
| Nick Chmura - Oberlin (171) |
| Kevin Hannum - Brooklyn (189) |
| John Stewart - Brooklyn (215) |
| Jesse Campbell - Black River (285) |
