First Team |
| Jon Clark - Wellington |
| Gabe Clark - Black River |
| Kory Conley - Wellington |
| Matt Herb - Keystone |
| Morgan Jones - Oberlin |
| Cory Neale - Brooklyn |
| Jarrod Ramirez - Brookside |
| Troy Simmons - Clearview |
| Dash Sokol - Clearview |
| Mike Telzrow - Lutheran West |
| Scott Voiers - Lutheran West |
| Logan Weiland - Buckeye |
|
Second Team |
| Richie Bics - Columbia |
| Brandon Bowen - Oberlin |
| Matt Chonko - Clearview |
| Andy Hofener - Lutheran West |
| Chaz Jordan - Buckeye |
| Aaron Lindstrom - Keystone |
| Lee Palmer - Columbia |
| Kris Robinson - Oberlin |
| Kyle Shaw - Keystone |
| Mike Smetana - Buckeye |
| Blake Sword - Wellington |
|
